Skip to Content

Tuttorosso Tomatoes vs. Hunt’s Tomatoes Challenge

Tomato Showdown: Tuttorosso vs. Hunt’s! A juicy comparison to help you choose the perfect canned tomatoes for your dishes.

The Tuttorosso Tomatoes challenge might change your mind about a can of tomatoes is a can of tomatoes, right? I’m going to show you the difference in the quality of tomatoes before you begin your recipe. Let’s face it; the best recipes start with the best ingredients. My grandmother taught me something, which makes my mom’s cooking unique. As a new mom, I lost sight of this, trying to stretch the budget; family recipes didn’t taste the same from my kitchen. Don’t get me wrong, I love a bargain, but when it comes to a recipe, I’m more about the quality of my ingredients.

Recently, I took the Tuttorosso Tomatoes Challenge.

A can of tomatoes is a can of tomatoes, right? I’m going to show you the difference in the quality of tomatoes before you begin your recipe. I prefer Tuttorosso–it’s the brand I put on our grocery list if my husband is shopping. For him, a can of tomatoes was opening and pouring into the recipe.

Here’s why I prefer Tuttorosso tomatoes over Hunt’s tomatoes.

We will be comparing Tuttorosso Whole Peeled Plum Tomatoes to Hunt’s Whole Peeled Plum Tomatoes. Both are 28-ounce cans.

tuttorosso vs hunt's

Here is the Nutritional Information from each brand:

tuttorosso vs hunts nutritional ingredients

Items Used for Tuttorosso Tomatoes vs. Hunt’s Tomatoes Comparison Challenge:

  • 28-ounce can Tuttorosso Plum Peeled Tomatoes
  • 28-ounce can Hung’s Whole Peeled Plum tomatoes
  • White styrofoam trays for each brand
  • can-opener
  • knife
  • strainer
  • scorecard

The Tuttorosso Tomatoes Challenge Step-by-Step

I first opened the can of Tuttorosso Tomatoes and gently poured the tomatoes and juice into the styrofoam tray.

I first opened the can of Tuttorosso Tomatoes and gently poured the tomatoes and juice into the styrofoam tray.

Next,  I opened the can of Hunt’s Tomatoes and gently poured the tomatoes and juice into the second styrofoam tray.hunts tomatoes 28 oz can

With the trays side-by-side, I placed the Tuttorosso can behind the corresponding tray and the Hunt’s can behind the corresponding tray.


tuttorossa vs hunts tomatoes in tray


Next, I examined the products side-by-side. I compared each brand’s appearance based on the rating scale: 1 for Poor Quality to 5 for Extraordinary Quality.

tuttorossa vs hunts side-by-side

I looked at the tomatoes and rated them on the following:

  • Red Color of Tomatoes
  • Uniformity of Size
  • Tomato Integrity

In looking at the Red of the Tomatoes, I asked:

  • How “red” are the tomatoes?

The brighter the hue of the red, the higher the score. The less red (or more orange/yellow shades), the lower the score.

In looking at the Uniformity of the Size of Tomatoes, I asked:

  • How similar in size are all the tomatoes in the sample?

The more minor variation in size, the higher the score. The more variation in size, the lower the score.

In looking at the Tomato Integrity, I asked:

  • How firm do the tomatoes look (without touching them)?

The more firm they look, the higher the score. The less firm (mushy) they look, the lower the score. (If the majority of tomatoes are broken and mashed “0”)

In the next part of the challenge, I moved the tomatoes to the top of the tray and propped up just enough to allow the juice to move away from the tomatoes. I pushed aside any broken tomatoes, yellow shoulders, tags (pieces of peel still attached), or tomato peels.

tuttorossa vs hunts propped up

Continuing the comparison, hunt's whole peeled tomato cut in half

tuttorossa tomato cut in half

Then I tasted the tomatoes and evaluated their intensity of flavor and flavor attributes.

For the last comparison, I poured the juice and tomatoes of each tray into a strainer and rinsed the tomatoes with water. Upon rinsing, I placed the tomatoes back onto the white tray to look for peels, broken or mashed pieces, yellow color, etc.

tuttorosso vs hunt's

During each test comparison, my husband was in awe of the differences between Tuttorosso and Hunt’s. The Hunt’s tomatoes had the PEEL on many of them. I point this out ONLY because Hunt’s label says explicitly, “Whole PEELED Plum Tomatoes.”

hunt's tomatoes still have peels

There is a difference that can be seen and tasted between the brands. I’m glad we choose the Tuttorosso Difference.

Here is my score sheet for the comparison between Tuttorosso and Hunt’s.

tuttorossa vs hunts comparison

I gave Tuttorosa 25/25 and Hunt’s 14/25.

My reasoning:

Tuttorosso Challenge Appearance:

The color of the Tuttorosso tomatoes is a deep, dark red. It resembles more the tomato I would pick from my garden. The Hunt’s tomatoes were a MUCH lighter red, bordering orange/yellow.

The uniformity of the Tuttorosso tomatoes was all similar in size and shape. The Hunt’s was a mod-podge of big and little tomatoes.

The tomato integrity had Tuttoross0 the leader again. The Tuttoross0 tomatoes looked plump and firm, while Hunt’s tomatoes looked soggy and collapsed.

Hunt’s was almost half the can when it came to the amount of peel and seeds present. You could see the seeds, and some of the tomatoes had more than one-half of their peel still attached. The Tuttoross0 tomatoes had no peels, and if any seeds were present, we did not see them.

The juice on the Tuttoross0 Tomatoes reminded me of my grandma’s canned tomato juice. It was a deep red and thick. It had immense flavor. The Hunt’s tomatoes were more like water, and I could see separating the juice and water.

As for the taste, Tuttorosso won hands down. The flavors were more like vine-picked. The Hunt’s tomatoes had a metallic taste, lacking the flavor.

We use Tuttorosso Tomatoes for my Minestrone Recipe and my Authentic Italian Sauce. I consider them to be the secret of the complex flavors and beautiful color of these finished dishes.

I encourage you to take the Tuttorosso Challenge with your favorite brand of tomatoes. After all, the best recipes start with the best ingredients.

I received the items to participate in the Tuttorosso Challenge as a Tuttorosso Tomatoes Ambassador. The opinions and photos expressed in this post are 100% my own.

Tuttorosso Tomatoes vs. Hunt's Tomatoes

About Julee: Julee Morrison is an experienced author with 35 years of expertise in parenting and recipes. She is the author of four cookbooks: The Instant Pot College Cookbook, The How-To Cookbook for Teens, The Complete Cookbook for Teens, and The Complete College Cookbook. Julee is passionate about baking, crystals, reading, and family. Her writing has appeared in The LA Times (Bon Jovi Obsession Goes Global), Disney's Family Fun Magazine (August 2010, July 2009, September 2008), and My Family Gave Up Television (page 92, Disney Family Fun August 2010). Her great ideas have been featured in Disney's Family Fun (Page 80, September 2008) and the Write for Charity book From the Heart (May 2010). Julee's work has also been published in Weight Watchers Magazine, All You Magazine (Jan. 2011, February 2011, June 2013), Scholastic Parent and Child Magazine (Oct. 2011), Red River Family Magazine (Jan. 2011),, and more. Notably, her article "My Toddler Stood on Elvis' Grave and Scaled Over Boulders to Get to a Dinosaur" made AP News, and "The Sly Way I Cured My Child's Lying Habit" was featured on PopSugar. When she's not writing, Julee enjoys spending time with her family and exploring new baking recipes.
error: Content is protected !!